|
Rating: (out of 4)
Is the reporting balanced; that is, does it give both sides of the issue? The press release reports only on a small study conducted with rodents. It does not provide alternate explanations for the symptoms seen in autism. (0)
Does the report sensationalize the material? Not really, but because it is a press release it may seem to have greater importance than it would have had if it had been published in a journal. (1)
Does the information come from a scientific journal? This is bench research that has not been tested out in human trials. There is published evidence that secretin does not work in children with autism. (0)
Does it fit with existing evidence about autism? Although there is evidence of some dysfunction of the amygdala in human children with autism, this work was done on rodents and does not have demonstrated applicability to humans. (0)
Rating: 1/4
|